Revised EHRC guidance on the duty to prevent sexual and third-party harassment
The guidance is not legally binding, but it is likely that employment tribunals will refer to it when determining whether employers are compliant. It covers employers' legal responsibilities, including their obligations under the preventative duty and the steps they must take to prevent sexual harassment at work, as well as preventative measures in respect of harassment by third parties.
The duty to prevent sexual harassment: reasonable steps
The guidance makes it clear that what amounts to reasonable steps will vary between employers and that different organisations may take different approaches to preventing sexual harassment. Whether an employer has taken all reasonable steps will be assessed objectively, taking into accounts the facts and circumstances of each situation.
The guidance makes it clear that an employer is unlikely to be able to comply with the preventative duty unless they carry out a risk assessment. It also states that if there are other steps that an employer could have taken to reduce risks but decides not to, then it is likely that the employer will have failed to comply with the preventative duty.
The guidance emphasises that a tribunal may conclude that a particular step was reasonable, even if it would not, on its own, have prevented the harassment from occurring. However, a step that is expensive, time consuming and troublesome to implement will not be a reasonable step to take if it will achieve nothing.
The importance of regular review and staff training
Employers should regularly assess whether the measures they have implemented are effective in preventing harassment. The guidance places significant emphasis on effective staff training, and explicitly mentions that case law has found that the fact that workers have attended anti-harassment training but have not understood it, or have chosen to ignore it, may be relevant in determining whether the all reasonable steps defence has been met.
Employers should continue to review whether there are any further steps that it would be practicable for them to take, taking into consideration whether there have been any changes in the workplace or the workforce and the availability of new technology such as new reporting systems.
Inclusive workplaces and the role of management
The guidance notes that inclusive workplaces are less likely to experience entrenched harassment. It also highlights the significant impact harassment can have on individuals, workplace culture and productivity. It emphasises the importance of employers taking the steps it outlines as a way of protecting workers against harassment, and highlights that management and senior leaders have a critical role in creating respectful workplaces that are free from harassment. They are called on to "role model respectful behaviour and visibly promote a positive and inclusive workplace culture where harassment is taken seriously and not tolerated".
The guidance also points to the critical role that middle managers and supervisors have, noting that workplace culture will be influenced by the positive behaviour they model and any negative behaviour they tolerate. It states that leaders and managers at all levels of an organisation are likely to benefit from behaviour-based training and stresses the importance of them responding appropriately and consistently to all harassment complaints.
Third party harassment
An employer will not be liable if they can show that they took all reasonable steps to prevent third party harassment occurring.
In meeting this obligation, employers are only required to take steps that are reasonable in their particular circumstances. Employers are not expected to take steps to guard against risks that are extremely unlikely to arise. A risk assessment should be carried out to identify the risks related to third party harassment and how they can be mitigated, and the employer should consult with staff, worker representatives or recognised trade unions to seek feedback on proposed measures. The guidance notes that an employer may wish to consider an anonymous survey to encourage openness.
Various examples of steps which it may be reasonable for employers to take depending on the circumstances include:
Display notices and include contractual provisions confirming that harassment is unlawful and will not be tolerated.
Remove third parties who engage in sexual harassment from business premises where practicable.
Avoid lone working and working in isolated areas where risks have been identified.
Install appropriate surveillance measures where justified.
Provide practical training on recognising early warning signs, responding safely, de-escalating behaviour and exiting abusive situations.
Ensure staff know how to report incidents involving third parties and that managers are trained to deal with reports appropriately.
Total bans on controversial views are unlikely to be proportionate
The guidance reminds employers to balance any preventative measures against the rights of third parties, including rights to freedom of expression and freedom of thought, conscience and religion. It notes that employers should avoid complete bans on all controversial views because these are unlikely to be proportionate. Employer policies should regulate inappropriate conduct rather than regulate the holding or expression of particular beliefs or opinions.
Policies
Employers will need to ensure that all workers are aware of their anti-harassment policies and ensure that these are freely available, either on an easily accessible part of their external-facing website, on a work intranet or by physically providing copies to each worker. These policies should also be shared with organisations that supply workers and services to ensure that all workers supplied to the employer are aware of the standards expected of them, and know how to report instances of harassment.
Anti-harassment policies and preventative measures should be regularly reviewed and evaluated to assess their effectiveness and identify any further action required. The guidance suggests that the effectiveness of the polices and steps taken can be evaluated through measures such as anonymised staff surveys.
Other suggested measures include holding lessons-learned sessions once complaints have been resolved, gathering feedback from worker representatives or recognised trade unions or gathering feedback provided through conversations with employees, for example, during exit interviews.
Practical steps
In practical terms, employers should focus on the following steps to comply with the preventative duty and minimise the risk of third-party harassment:
Keep your policies up-to-date and under review to determine whether they are effective.
Carry out a risk assessment and keep it under review making sure that you consult with employee or trade union representatives to ensure it is fully comprehensive.
Ensure that senior staff and managers model positive behaviours and make it clear that negative behaviour is not tolerated.
Put in place training for all staff, make sure they understand it and ensure that it is refreshed on a regular basis.
Make sure that staff know how to report inappropriate behaviour and consider carrying out lessons-learned sessions once complaints have been resolved.
The guidance contains a number of useful examples illustrating the practical steps employers can take to prevent both sexual and third-party harassment.
How we can help
Our Banter and Harassment Toolkit provides practical advice to help employers create respectful workplaces and comply with their legal obligations. If you would like support reviewing your current arrangements, please get in touch.