What contracting authorities need to know about the Procurement Compliance Service
The PCS forms part of the Cabinet Office's Procurement Compliance and Oversight (PCO) function, which aims to improve the capability and practices of contracting authorities for the benefit of everyone involved in public procurement. This is said to be achieved through overseeing general compliance with procurement legislation, investigating potential instances of non-compliance, issuing recommendations or guidance to contracting authorities.
What is the PCS?
The PCO consists of two distinct services: the PCS and the Public Procurement Review Service (PPRS). The PCS investigates potential non-compliance with the requirements of the Act by contracting authorities. The PCS's remit is broad, covering central government and wider public sector bodies including NHS organisations, local authorities and universities. Referrals can be made by anyone, and the PCS may also identify potential non-compliance through its own monitoring of the Central Digital Platform. Not every referral leads to an investigation.
The PCS applies a risk-based triage, assessing financial impact, scale of procurement exposure, public impact and the seriousness of the potential compliance failure. Where a case is not investigated immediately, it is logged and may be revisited if further referrals or information are received.
Where a formal investigation is opened under section 108 of the Act, contracting authorities have a statutory obligation to assist, including by providing relevant documents. Following an investigation, the PCS issues a report setting out its findings and recommendations, which may be published on GOV.UK. The PCS can also require contracting authorities to submit progress reports and can publish notice where a contracting authority fails to do so.
A key area of focus: the vertical arrangements exception
It seems that one area attracting early PCS attention is the vertical arrangements exception, sometimes called the "Teckal exemption". The exception allows contracts to be awarded between a contracting authority and an entity it controls without a competitive procurement process, on the basis that the authority is in effect contracting with another part of itself. The conditions are more demanding than they might first appear. All of the following must be satisfied:
• Control: the contracting authority must be a "parent undertaking" of the other entity, as defined by reference to section 1162 of the Companies Act 2006, and no other person may exert a decisive influence over the controlled entity's activities.
• The 80% activities test: more than 80% of the controlled entity's activities must be carried out for or on behalf of the controlling authority, calculated using three years' turnover ending on the date of contract award.
• No private share ownership: no shares in the controlled entity may be held by any person who is not a contracting authority.
• Joint control: where control is shared between multiple contracting authorities, each must be represented on the controlled entity's board, and the entity must not act contrary to any controlling authority's interests.
Practical considerations
• Keep your records in order. A PCS information request will typically require a contracting authority to produce procurement documentation at short notice, including governance documents, contract and procurement registers. Contracting authorities that cannot readily produce a clear and coherent audit trail are at a significant disadvantage when responding, regardless of whether the underlying decision was legally sound. Maintaining robust procurement records as a matter of course is therefore essential.
• Take legal advice early. An initial information request from the PCS is not a formal investigation, but it sets the terms on which the PCS will assess whether to open one. The framing, tone and content of an initial response can be determinative. Contracting authorities may therefore want to seek legal advice before responding, even where they are confident in the underlying legality of their procurement decisions.
• Consider the reputational dimension. PCS investigation reports may be published on GOV.UK, alongside any notices issued where a contracting authority fails to implement recommendations.
• Could the referral itself be challenged? The PCS will typically not investigate where a query appears malicious or vexatious, or where there is an unsubstantiated or generalised suspicion of poor practice lacking sufficient evidence. Where a contracting authority has grounds to believe a referral was made in bad faith, raising that point alongside substantive compliance assurances may be a relevant factor in the triage decision, but the primary focus should remain on demonstrating substantive compliance to the Act.
• Freedom of Information. All documents submitted to the PCS are held by the Cabinet Office and are potentially subject to disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA). Even where commercially sensitive material is flagged as such, the PCS cannot guarantee confidentiality. Contracting authorities should prepare submissions with potential downstream disclosure in mind and take advice on which FOIA exemptions are most likely to be available.
Conclusion
The PCS is a body with real powers and contracting authorities should familiarise themselves with how it operates, ensure their use of exemptions such as the vertical arrangements exception is rigorously documented, and treat any initial information request with the seriousness it deserves. Whilst not a formal investigation it is the gateway to one.